Should I charge a public holiday surcharge for my small business?

What are public holiday surcharges?

A public holiday surcharge is an additional fee that businesses charge customers for services or goods provided on a public holiday. This surcharge helps offset the higher costs businesses face during these times, such as increased wages, utility expenses, and potentially reduced operating hours.

For instance, if you own a café, you might charge an extra 10% on your menu prices on a public holiday. This helps cover the penalty rates you must pay your staff while maintaining profit margins. Without such a surcharge, your business could operate at a loss on these days, especially if labour costs consume a significant portion of your expenses.

Public holiday surcharges are most common in the hospitality industry but can also appear in retail, healthcare, and entertainment sectors.

‍

Should I charge a public holiday surcharge?

Charging a public holiday surcharge depends on your business's financial circumstances, industry standards, and customer base. Here are some factors to consider:

1. Labour costs

Public holidays often incur employee penalty rates, significantly inflating your wage bill. If your staff costs are already high, absorbing the additional expense might not be sustainable. A surcharge can help offset these costs and ensure your business remains profitable.

2. Customer expectations

Understanding your customers' perspectives is crucial. Some customers recognise that public holidays result in higher business costs and are willing to pay a surcharge. However, others might view the additional fee negatively, especially if it isn't justified. You should tread carefully if your clientele values transparency and fairness.

3. Competitor practices

Research what similar businesses in your area are doing. If surcharges are standard practice, implementing one might not deter customers. Conversely, if competitors avoid surcharges, you might gain a competitive edge by doing the same. Consider whether standing out as a surcharge-free business aligns with your long-term goals.

4. Brand values

Your brand identity should play a significant role in your decision. If your business prides itself on affordability and customer-first principles, adding a surcharge could conflict with those values. On the other hand, if your brand emphasises quality and sustainability, customers might be more understanding of a surcharge designed to cover fair wages and operational costs.

Is it legal to charge a public holiday surcharge?

Yes, charging a public holiday surcharge is legal in Australia, provided you comply with consumer protection laws. Under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), businesses must be transparent about pricing. If you choose to apply a surcharge, you must display it and communicate it to customers before they make a purchase.

Transparency is key to avoiding accusations of misleading or deceptive conduct. Ensure the surcharge is prominently displayed on menus, pricing boards, or your website. Failing to do so can result in penalties and damage your reputation.

‍

How much can a public holiday surcharge be?

There are no fixed regulations on how much you can charge as a public holiday surcharge. However, the amount must be reasonable and proportionate to your increased costs.

The surcharge should cover expenses like penalty rates and additional operational costs without appearing excessive. A reasonable surcharge typically ranges between 10% and 15%, which most customers find acceptable. Anything significantly higher may require additional justification, such as unique circumstances or premium offerings.

What is the average public holiday surcharge?

In Australia, public holiday surcharges in the hospitality industry generally range from 10% to 15%. This range is considered fair and aligns with most customers' expectations. Businesses in other sectors may vary their surcharge depending on their cost structure and market conditions.

Higher surcharges, such as 20% or more, are rare and usually limited to high-end establishments or businesses with exceptionally high labour costs. If you're considering a higher surcharge, ensure it is justified and communicated to customers.

‍

Is it a legal requirement to pay public holiday rates?

In many industries, paying penalty rates on public holidays is a legal requirement under the Fair Work Act. These rates compensate employees for working during times typically reserved for rest and leisure.

Penalty rates vary depending on the applicable award or enterprise agreement but can range from 150% to 250% of the standard hourly rate. For example, employees in the hospitality industry often receive double time or time-and-a-half for working on public holidays.

Ensure you understand your obligations under the relevant industrial agreements to avoid compliance issues. Non-compliance with wage laws can lead to severe penalties and reputational damage.

How should I communicate public holiday surcharges to customers?

Clear and upfront communication is essential when implementing a public holiday surcharge. Customers are more likely to accept the additional fee if they understand its purpose and feel informed before purchasing.

• Use signage: Place clear and visible signage at the entrance to your business, on your menu, or at the point of sale. Ensure the surcharge is highlighted prominently and includes the exact percentage and applicable dates.
• Update your online presence: Inform customers about the surcharge through your website and social media platforms. This will allow potential customers to know about it in advance, reducing the likelihood of complaints.
• Be clear on receipts: Include the surcharge as a separate line item on receipts. Label it as "Public Holiday Surcharge" to maintain transparency and avoid confusion. For example, you could use a notice like: "A 10% public holiday surcharge applies today to cover increased operational costs." This phrasing is professional and informative.

What should I do if a customer complains about a public holiday surcharge?

Complaints about surcharges can arise, but how you handle them can make a significant difference. Here's a step-by-step approach:

1. Listen carefully: Allow the customer to express their concerns fully. Show empathy and acknowledge their frustration.
2. Provide a clear explanation: Explain why the surcharge exists, focusing on the increased costs your business incurs on public holidays. Highlight your commitment to fair employee compensation and maintaining service quality.
3. Point to your communication efforts: Politely remind the customer about where the surcharge was displayed or communicated. Reassure them that transparency is a priority for your business.
4. Offer a resolution: If the situation escalates, consider offering a small goodwill gesture, such as a discount or voucher. This can help preserve the customer relationship while showing that you value their feedback.

Key takeaways

Deciding whether to charge a public holiday surcharge is a complex but crucial decision for small business owners in Australia. By weighing up financial needs, customer expectations, and industry practices, you can determine whether a surcharge aligns with your goals. Transparency and clear communication are essential to implementing a surcharge successfully. With a well-thought-out approach, you can balance profitability with customer satisfaction and maintain your business's reputation.