Cash stuffing envelope system: Does it work for business?

What is ‘cash stuffing’?

Cash stuffing, or envelope budgeting, is a way to manage money by dividing monthly income into different spending categories. This method has been popular on platforms like TikTok, breathing fresh air into a classic tactic. Individuals label envelopes with specific categories such as groceries, rent, or student loans. 

They then place the allocated cash for each category into the corresponding envelope. Traditionally, this approach involved actual cash and envelopes, operating every month.

How the cash stuffing method works

Begin with a financial plan.

The cash stuffing strategy thrives with a well-constructed financial plan. Start by allocating your income wisely. An approach such as the 50/30/20 budget can be effective. It suggests spending 50% of your income on necessities like rent and groceries, 30% on leisure activities, and allocating the remaining 20% to savings and debt repayment.

For instance, with a monthly income of $3,500, you might divide it as follows:

• Needs: $1,750
• Wants: $1,050
• Savings and debt: $700

This example demonstrates one way to manage your funds, and you can certainly tailor it to your preferences. The main goal is to develop a budget that helps monitor spending and reinforces financial discipline.

Organise your spending categories.

Think about your usual expenses and categorise them. Categories might vary from something broad like "leisure" to something specific like "cinema" or "dining out." Each category should have its own envelope.

Label each envelope with its designated category and fill it with the cash amount you’ve budgeted for that category. This step is where the "cash stuffing" part happens. You are tangibly allocating funds to different parts of your life, which helps in visualising and controlling spending.

Spend only what’s in the envelopes.

To maintain financial discipline, spend only using the cash from the relevant envelope. If you have $50 saved for coffee and purchase a $5 drink, reduce the contents of your envelope accordingly. You would then have $45 left for coffee for the rest of the month.

Some choose to replenish their envelopes monthly, while others do so following each payday. The key is to ensure that spending stays within the boundaries you’ve set through your budget categories, allowing you to track cash transactions and maintain financial control efficiently.

Cash stuffing for businesses

While primarily associated with personal finance, the core principles of cash stuffing can be adapted to benefit small businesses. By creating separate "envelopes" or accounts for different expense categories (e.g., rent, utilities, marketing, inventory), business owners can visually track their spending and ensure they stay within their budget.

• Improved cash flow management: Cash stuffing can enhance a business' cash flow visibility. By allocating specific amounts to different envelopes, owners can avoid overspending in certain areas and ensure enough cash is available for essential expenses.
• Reduced impulse spending:  Just as with individuals, businesses can be prone to impulse purchases. The tangible nature of cash stuffing can make business owners more mindful of their expenditures, potentially leading to cost savings.
• Simplified budgeting: The simplicity of cash stuffing can make budgeting less intimidating for small business owners. It's a hands-on approach that requires minimal accounting knowledge.

The advantages

One of the key benefits of the cash stuffing envelope system is the avoidance of overdraft fees commonly associated with debit and credit card use. Dividing money into separate envelopes provides a tangible way to manage spending, making users more aware of their financial situation. This approach can help individuals track their purchases and avoid impulse buying.

Creating specific categories for different expenses can help manage variable expenses, which often strain budgets. Setting aside cash amounts for categories such as dining out or entertainment makes it clearer how resources are being allocated. This method contributes to a stronger sense of financial control, as budgeters can see exactly where their money is going.

Physical cash can also foster a deeper connection to money due to its tangible nature. People may become more cautious with their spending because parting with cash feels more significant than swiping a card. Studies suggest that cash users often spend less, enhancing mindful spending habits.

Additional advantages include developing a positive money mindset and focusing on money goals. The envelope method encourages individuals to be deliberate and intentional with how they use their funds, potentially aiding in the growth of an emergency fund or achieving financial aspirations over time. This deepens the understanding of personal finances and aligns spending habits with monetary targets.

Potential downsides

While cash stuffing offers several benefits for small businesses, it's important to be aware of its limitations:

• Limited scalability: As a business expands and its financial transactions become more complex, managing numerous cash envelopes can become cumbersome and prone to errors.
• Lack of financial insights: Cash stuffing primarily focuses on spending control and may not provide a comprehensive picture of a business's financial health. It can be challenging to track income, generate profit and loss statements, or analyse trends using this method alone.
• Missed opportunities:  By strictly allocating funds to pre-determined envelopes, businesses might miss out on potential growth opportunities or struggle to adapt to unexpected expenses or market changes.
• Operational inefficiencies: Manually counting cash, making frequent bank deposits, and reconciling transactions can be time-consuming and inefficient, particularly for businesses with high transaction volumes. Profit First's use of bank accounts and automated allocations streamlines financial management, saving time and reducing the risk of errors.

Addressing the downsides with Profit First

Profit First is a cash management system that addresses many of the limitations of cash stuffing, offering a more comprehensive and strategic approach to managing business finances.

• Prioritisng profit: Unlike cash stuffing, which primarily focuses on expense control, Profit First emphasises allocating a portion of revenue to profit first, ensuring profitability from the outset.
• Multiple bank accounts:  Profit First recommends using multiple bank accounts to separate income, expenses, profit, owner's pay, and taxes. This system enhances financial clarity and prevents overspending.
• Regular allocation: Instead of relying on cash envelopes, Profit First involves regularly allocating percentages of revenue to different accounts based on a predetermined formula. This approach automates the budgeting process and promotes consistent financial discipline.

Read more about Profit First and find out why it is more effective for businesses.

Set up your Profit First with Thriday

Thriday can help you implement Profit First seamlessly, providing the tools and guidance you need to optimise your cash flow, prioritise profitability, and build a sustainable business.

With Thriday, you get:

• Easy Profit First setup: We'll walk you through the whole process, from setting up your bank accounts to automating those all-important allocations.
• Real-time financial insights: Our platform gives you a crystal-clear view of your business's financial health, so you always know where you stand.
• Data-driven decision making:  Use our analytics and reports to identify trends, track key metrics, and make informed choices that drive your business forward.

Fret not, we have a guide to help you set your Profit First account.

Final thoughts

Cash stuffing offers a tangible and visual approach to budgeting, promoting financial awareness and discipline. However, its limitations make it less suitable for businesses. Profit First, with its focus on profitability and streamlined financial management, presents a more comprehensive solution for businesses seeking sustainable growth and financial success.

Frequently asked questions

Is cash stuffing suitable for everyone?

Cash stuffing can be beneficial for individuals who struggle with overspending or prefer a tangible budgeting method. However, it may not be ideal for those who rely heavily on digital payments or find managing cash inconvenient.

Which system is better for a small business just starting out?

Both systems can be beneficial for small businesses, but the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you prefer a tangible, hands-on approach and have relatively simple finances, cash stuffing might be a good starting point. However, if you're looking for a more scalable and comprehensive system that prioritises profitability from the beginning, Profit First is the better option.

Can I switch from cash stuffing to Profit First?

Absolutely!  Transitioning from cash stuffing to Profit First involves setting up the necessary bank accounts and implementing the Profit First allocation percentages. Thriday can guide you through this process and provide ongoing support.

‍